Trials in Family Court
Why avoid trials?
It is advisable to avoid trials because they are costly and time-consuming. Following a trial, co-parenting may become more challenging. In addition, a third party makes critical decisions, and changing the court order may be impossible without returning to court. Finally, you must comply with the order or risk serious legal repercussions.
How are offers to settle used to minimize costs and avoid trial?
Offers to settle are used to save costs and avert trial by making a clear, reasonable, and fair solution to end a legal dispute. These solutions can help parties achieve an agreement, perhaps saving time and money on a trial. Offers to settle may also include requests that the opposing party pay legal fees. However, the trial judge cannot find out about the offer until after their decision has been made.
Which family law rules cover evidence and trials?
Rule 23 of the Family Law Rules covers evidence and trials.
What does setting down for trial mean?
“Setting down for trial” refers to formally scheduling a court date for a family law case that will be heard and determined by a judge. It is the moment in the legal procedure at which the dispute is officially marked for trial, and both sides are informed of the date and time when their case is scheduled to be examined in court.
How do you prepare your trial record?
To prepare for your trial record, first gather any trial-related materials. Then, build a table of contents that includes all of the documents. Include copies of your initial application, the respondent’s response, and any answers or agreed-upon declarations of facts. Also include evaluation reports, reports from the Office of the Children’s Lawyer, and any temporary orders. Make sure to include necessary transcripts and trial scheduling forms. and make sure all financial documentation, such as financial statements, certificates of financial disclosure, and net family property statements, are up to date. Next, serve the trial record on all parties at least 20 days before the trial and submit it with the court within that time range.
Can the respondent add to the trial record?
If you are the respondent, you can examine the trial record when it arrives, add any documents that are absent, update the table of contents, and serve and file any additional papers at least seven days before the trial.
What evidence you can use at trial?
Documents or witnesses can be used as evidence during a trial. Documents, known as exhibits, must be legitimate and relevant to the case, such as pay stubs used to prove income for child support. Documents can be presented when testifying as a witness or questioning a witness who can speak about them. Before trial, the opposing side should be given copies of these documents, preferably in the form of a document brief. Witnesses can present evidence based on personal knowledge opposed to hearsay. They can support your case by revealing what they know.
What are the steps in a trial?
- Each side provides an opening statement.
- Introduction of evidence: applicant first, then respondent
- Direct examination of evidence
- Cross-examination of evidence, then a re-examination of witnesses to clear anything up if needed
- Each side provides a closing statement.
What is court etiquette, including behaviours to avoid?
To maintain proper courtroom decorum, dress in appropriate attire and arrive at least 15 minutes before the hearing. Except for water, which is authorized, no food or drink can be taken into the courtroom. Avoid chewing gum and remember to turn off your phones and devices. Maintain a pleasant and respectful demeanor during the proceedings. Stand when the judge enters and exits the courtroom, and address him/her as “Your Honour.” When speaking to the judge, address them directly unless you are questioning a witness. Use formal titles such as Ms., Mr., or Mrs. instead of first names. Respectful listening is essential; avoid interrupting and let one person talk at a time.
What people you will see in the courtroom?
- Judge
- Court reporter
- Court registrar
- Court service officers
- Duty counsel
- Children’s lawyer
- Lawyers
What is the judge’s role
The judge’s role is to be the “referee” during the trial; be fair and impartial to the case by listening to both sides. They explain the law to the jury and parties involved and make procedural rulings. They make decisions concerning objections and summarize the law and evidence relating to the case, by the end of the trial.
What is the court registrar’s role?
The role of the court registrar is to receive any exhibits or documents and hand this material to the judge before the trial commences.
What is the difference between direct examination and cross-examination?
Direct examination occurs when a party’s own witness is questioned by their lawyer. The goal is to inform the court what the witness observed; the main objective here is to support the party’s position. In contrast, cross-examination occurs when the opposing party’s lawyer questions the witness. The goal is to assess the credibility of the witness’ testimony, dispute inconsistencies, or reveal facts that may discredit the opposing party’s position.
What are opening statements?
The opening statement is a brief overview of the case. Include facts that are not likely to be challenged by the opposing side, and speak in short, clear sentences.
What are closing statements?
Closing comments are your final opportunity to address the judge before a decision is rendered: be clear and concise. They should properly convey your side’s stance and the legal justifications why you should win. To prepare, jot down relevant arguments and data to support your position. Speak in brief, straightforward phrases and only relate to evidence produced at trial. Adjust your closing arguments as needed to reflect the progress of the trial. Highlight any admissions made by the opposing side’s witnesses that support your claim. Lastly, coordinate with the lawyer who drafted your opening statement to ensure consistency and thorough discussion of crucial facts.
How do you prepare for direct examination?
To prepare for direct examination, note down everything that your side is attempting to prove and re-read your witness’ testimony to gain more relevant facts to support your case. Emphasize the facts that your witness must talk about. Create questions that help the witness tell a story, but keep them short and simple. Ensure you do not ask leading questions, also known as questions that lead one to a specific answer.
How do you prepare for cross examination?
List the facts in the witness’ testimony that will support your case, and emphasize the facts that you wish to make the witness talk more about and admit to. Find ways to challenge the witness’ credibility, and create questions that lead one to answer with a simple yes or no.
A sample trial
|
Clerk calls to order, calls case and counsel introduction |
2 mins |
|
Applicant’s opening statement |
3 mins |
|
Respondent’s opening statement |
3 mins |
APPLICANT’S CASE
|
Applicant’s direct examination of applicant witness #1 |
10 mins |
|
Respondent’s cross examination |
10 mins |
|
Applicant’s direct examination of applicant witness #2 |
10 mins |
|
Respondent’s cross-examination |
10 mins |
RESPONDENT’S CASE
|
Respondent’s direct examination of applicant witness #1 |
10 mins |
|
Applicant’s cross examination |
10 mins |
|
Respondent’s direct examination of applicant witness #2 |
10 mins |
|
Applicant’s cross-examination |
10 mins |
CLOSING ARGUMENTS
|
Applicant’s closing argument |
15 mins |
|
Respondent’s closing argument |
15 mins |
|
Judge provides feedback and discusses the family trial process |
10 mins |